Over the last ten years, we experienced the evolution of HTML to Video conversion. At the forefront of this transformation, our service has been dedicated to overcoming common hurdles, delivering universal compatibility, ensuring the highest quality video outputs on the best price and uncompromised speed. This guide summarises a decade of insights into best practices for seamless HTML to video conversion.
8 Different Solutions and Applications
As it comes to html animation to video conversion, there are plenty of diverse solutions to pick from. Here we try to summarize and categorize the most popular available software and services highlighting both the positive and the negative aspects of each.
1. Html2.Videos SaaS Solution: This complex solution has ten years of operational background with convincing references. The offer focuses on API control in an SaaS business construction, scaling included. The published timing JS API provides precise timing of the animation, and the controlled environment has GPU support and sound. Soundtrack and video is recorded in a single shot, so timing and frame-skipping is minimalized. The animation is rendered in a full-stack real browser. The html2.video services offer an on-demand solution API where animations can be directly generated and accessed on-the-fly demonstrated here. Queue and access is balanced: there is minimal queue time lost. They offer business solutions on reasonable prices to integrate with custom services.
2. Manual Screen Capture: Ffmpeg, Snipping Tool, or a Chrome Extension are all able to capture the desktop of the user, and there are probably dozens more. There are many other software (e.g. screencasting and broadcasting) which support just that. These tools are a good choice for a single-shot job, and using them results in awesome explanation and videos. However none of these are automated, or remotely accessible vi an API. Start-stop and quality / compression settings are also limiting factors: they vary individually. These are generic tools for capturing your screen, not just your browser or a html based animation.
3. Html File Conversion by Desktop Software: There are specific desktop (Windows) software available to convert html sites to video, e.g. this one. They excel mostly on single, simple html documents, they might even support GPU acceleration and batch processing. Software is localized, and do not offer any API or similar functionality to process videos on demand, neither can they include dynamic remote content in the process. Start-stop detection is missing.
4. Online HTML File to Video Converters: The online available versions of the above software (e.g. this tool in online-convert.com or this one on aconvert.com ) have the ability to convert animations from single files sent them. No GPU support or start-stop-detection and dynamic content is a missing point.
5. Puppeteer based solutions: The principle here is that Puppeteer can run a headless browser and capture its graphical output as single frames, then assemble the frames into a continuous video. Since Puppeteer is for testing various Front-End components this feature seems to be steadily supported. There is an Open Source code example to do just this on Github called videoshow with an explanatory video on YouTube showing how to use the code. This solution requires some technical skills to implement, and then simple animations can be rendered accordingly. This method produces lots of artifacts (jumps, inproper timing of frames), since the JS implementation in Puppeteers headless browser is not full, lacks GPU support, and is really slow: collecting screenshots and assembling them costs time. API is not included, but this code example can be implemented as any internal solution later.
6. NodeJS, Chromedriver and Chrome: Almost the best solution so far, there is a YouTube video from the channel LearnWebCode, where it is demonstrated working. Using this to control the browser, and recording audio and video on playback is what we used on the predecessor of Html2Video to generate tens of thousands of videos. The browser - in the proper environment - supports GPU acceleration; with the added JS control elements the NodeJS code can directly access the variables and functions in the animation, and provides smooth timing and playback control. Sound is supported, speed and efficiency is given since browsers come optimized. However this costs on CPU and control effectiveness: Chromedriver eats a lot of CPU, and the browsers thread management is confined. The result is resource depriving, complex videos are somewhat hard to render quickly.
7. On-line implementation of stepper + sound: We are not entirely sure how html5animationtogif.com works, but it shows the capacity of recording the animation with sound plus API. The process is definetively queued, there seems to be lacking GPU support, and there is no option for timing control except manual. On-line demo with watermarked results is available.
8. WebRTC Internal Recording: The browser - and its universal JS machine can be exploited to capture the generated image and sound - resulting a video. This Library on Github does just that, it comes with a Live Demo. This is also a localized solution and not an SaaS, controls are limited to the very tab where it is running, sensitive to a lot disturbances and artifacts, and the functions are somewhat limited. Timing and sizing of the recorded window is manual.
Table of Futures
| # | Solution Type | API Control | GPU Support | Timing Control | Single-Shot Recording | Fully Automated | Fast Conversion | Sound Support | Business Solution | Scalable |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Html2.Videos SaaS Solution | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| 2 | Manual Screen Capture | - | Yes | - | Yes | - | - | Yes | - | - |
| 3 | Html File Conversion by Desktop Software | - | Yes | - | Yes | Partially | - | Yes | - | - |
| 4 | Online HTML File to Video Converters | - | - | - | - | Yes | - | - | - | - |
| 5 | Puppeteer based solutions | - | - | - | - | Yes | - | - | - | Yes |
| 6 | NodeJS, Chromedriver and Chrome | - | Yes | - | Yes | Yes | - | Yes | - | - |
| 7 | On-line implementation of stepper + sound | Yes | - | - | - | Yes | - | Yes | Yes | - |
| 8 | WebRTC Internal Recording | - | Yes | - | Yes | - | - | Yes | - | - |
What Could Go Wrong?
HTML to video conversion is complex, often resulting in artifacts that degrade the quality of the final product. Here are list of the most common ones we faced.
Screen Tearing: This occurs when the video frame is not in sync with the display's refresh rate, causing a split frame appearance. Different other problems can also result in torn frames, e.g. resource exhaustion.
Missing Frames: When frames are skipped or lost during conversion, the video stream needs to be backfilled with images. The standard solution is to repeat the last image until a new image is available. This presents itself like choppy playback. In the final video this can be seen as a frame duplication exactly where smooth transient is expected.
Codec Issues: Incompatibilities between video codecs and playback devices can lead to errors or inability to play videos. There are different standards and patents which almost prohibit universal playback. The few exceptions needs to be found and properly parametrized.
Resolution Mismatches: Videos rendered in resolutions not supported by playback devices can lead to poor viewing experiences.
Active Window:Failing to locate the frame where the animation plays results in missing borders, or white/black framings in the video.
Color Tables: Incorrect color rendering can result from mismatches in color profiles between the HTML content and the video output. Graphic professionals can spot these errors, because color accuracy is key in marketing and display industries.
Missing Elements in HTML: Some HTML elements or complex animations may not render correctly in the final video.
Cross-Platform Compatibility Issues: Ensuring videos play seamlessly across Mac, Windows, Linux, and embedded devices in displays poses significant challenges.
Queue-Management: FIFO, LIFO, but the Customer wants the video now. If processing capacity is just a bit less than the demand, someone has to wait. Capacity management is crucial, that is why many customers chose us.
Start-Stop Timing: Missing the start of the animation, or recording it too long when it already finished, and then the screen might be just empty.
Our Answers
Full Browser with GPU Support: By leveraging a full-functional browser backed by dedicated GPU support, we ensure every element of the HTML is accurately rendered, including complex animations and interactive elements.
Optimized Hardware and Control: Our infrastructure runs on high-performance machines, optimized for video rendering. This combination of powerful hardware and precise control over the rendering process ensures animations are produced quickly and in the best possible quality.
Animation Timing Precision: Through our proprietary JavaScript API, we achieve timing accuracy within 10 milliseconds. This precision ensures animations are synchronized perfectly with audio and other video elements.
Flexible Connection Strategies: Our API enables callbacks, push-data, or any custom connection to our clients already existing Ecosystem. Finished videos can be uploaded to any cloud provider or CDN network.
Methods
While tools like Puppeteer and Chromedriver offer HTML to video conversion capabilities, they suffer from several limitations:
Performance: These solutions are significantly slower and less efficient than our service, primarily but not exclusively due to their lack of direct access to optimized hardware and advanced rendering capabilities.
Control and Elements: Puppeteer and Chromedriver do not load all elements during the conversion process, leading to missing elements.
Frame-assembly: Assembling the generated frames (Puppeteer) often results in jumpy scenes in an animation, because scene precision is missing
How Html2Video Solves
HTML2.Video's rendering environment is a masterpiece of technological synergy, designed to tackle the most intricate aspects of video production:
Full-Stack Browser: At the heart of HTML2.Video's rendering capabilities lies a full-stack browser, capable of interpreting and rendering complex HTML, CSS, and JavaScript just as a high-end desktop browser would. This ensures that all dynamic content, interactive elements, and advanced web technologies are fully supported.
Millisecond Precise Timing Control: Precision is paramount in video production. HTML2.Video achieves an unprecedented level of control, with timing accuracy that reaches down to the millisecond. This meticulous synchronization ensures that animations, transitions, and audio are perfectly aligned, providing a seamless viewing experience.
GPU Resources and Dedicated Hardware: By harnessing the power of dedicated GPU resources, HTML2.Video accelerates the rendering process, enabling the production of visually stunning videos with intricate animations and effects. The service runs on dedicated hardware, optimized for video rendering, ensuring both speed and quality are maximized.
The Results Speak Volumes
The efficiency of HTML2.Video's rendering process is evident in its output speed — videos are ready within 120% of their original length, often produced on-the-fly. This rapid turnaround is essential for applications requiring immediate video content delivery, from marketing campaigns to interactive displays.
DooH
One of the most innovative applications of HTML2.Video is in the realm of Digital Out-of-Home (DooH) displays. By leveraging real-time data, these displays can show personalized content to each passerby. HTML2.Video facilitates this by allowing dynamic data to be injected into the HTML parameters of an animation, making the content as responsive and tailored as possible. This capability opens up new avenues for engaging and interactive advertising, transforming the way brands connect with their audience.
HTML2.Video collaborates with industry leaders like Bannerflow and Emaze, ensuring that the service remains at the cutting edge of technology and creativity. This partnership approach fosters innovation, driving advancements in HTML to video conversion that benefit a wide range of applications. The emphasis on creating responsive, adaptable content means that videos produced by HTML2.Video are not just visually appealing but also highly effective in achieving their intended impact.
Conclusion
HTML2.Video redefines the landscape of HTML to video conversion through its advanced rendering environment, unparalleled precision, and the ability to produce content on-the-fly. Its application in DooH displays showcases the service's versatility and potential for personalization, making it a valuable tool for marketers and content creators. In collaboration with industry leaders, HTML2.Video continues to push the boundaries of what's possible, ensuring that videos are not just seen but experienced.
Contact Us
